14. Historical Fiction

January 11, 2021

Description

Is the author’s responsibility to the quality of the novel or the truth of history? What makes a great historical novel and which authors have contributed to our understanding of history. Tom...
Read more here

Books Referenced

Aubrey-Maturin series

Author: Patrick O'Brian

Context:

Discussed as naval historical fiction that Tom couldn't get through - gave up after 30 pages due to too much rope/nautical detail

Hornblower series

Author: C.S. Forester

Context:

Mentioned as naval fiction Emma Darwin grew up on, and Tom says he wasn't interested in either

In Search of Lost Time

Author: Marcel Proust

Context:

Referenced in a tweet comparing giving up on O'Brian to giving up on Proust after three pages because it's just about cake

The Eagle of the Ninth

Author: Rosemary Sutcliff

Context:

Mentioned as a classic way people come to Roman Britain through fiction, described as having enduring influence

The Sword at Sunset

Author: Rosemary Sutcliff

Context:

Described as a fabulous novel for adults about a historical Arthur in the 5th century after the Romans left

Asterix

Author: René Goscinny and Albert Uderzo

Context:

Tom mentions these comics/graphic novels as what got him particularly interested in the Romans

Wolf Hall trilogy

Author: Hilary Mantel

Context:

Discussed as the most successful/prestigious historical novels of the last ten years, with Thomas Cromwell as protagonist

A Man for All Seasons

Author: Robert Bolt

Context:

Mentioned as presenting opposite view to Hilary Mantel - Thomas More as hero rather than villain

A Game of Thrones series

Author: George R.R. Martin

Context:

Discussed as fantasy novels that take elements from Wars of the Roses but with unpredictable outcomes

The Accursed Kings series

Author: Maurice Druon

Context:

French series set in Hundred Years' War that partly inspired Game of Thrones

The White Company

Author: Arthur Conan Doyle

Context:

Mentioned as set in Hundred Years' War from English side, featuring Sir John Chandos and the Black Prince

Sir Nigel

Author: Arthur Conan Doyle

Context:

Mentioned alongside The White Company as Hundred Years' War fiction

An Instance of the Fingerpost

Author: Iain Pears

Context:

Nominated as the single best historical novel Tom has read - offers multiple perspectives on Restoration England

Shardlake series

Author: C.J. Sansom

Context:

Mentioned as very gripping novels, though criticized for having liberal humanist sceptic protagonist

The Last Kingdom series

Author: Bernard Cornwell

Context:

Set in Anglo-Saxon period, criticized for protagonist Uhtred being a 21st century liberal trapped in historical setting

The Leopard

Author: Giuseppe Tomasi di Lampedusa

Context:

Called a brilliant book about Italian unification, conservative in nature about anxiety of change

War and Peace

Author: Leo Tolstoy

Context:

Described as probably the most famous historical novel, noted for being about history itself and how history works

Crime and Punishment

Author: Fyodor Dostoevsky

Context:

Tom mentions being commissioned by The Economist to write about it, visiting St. Petersburg in Raskolnikov's footsteps

I, Claudius

Author: Robert Graves

Context:

Praised as the most successful attempt to ventriloquise someone from before the invention of the novel

Count Belisarius

Author: Robert Graves

Context:

Mentioned as incredibly boring because it reads like a Byzantine account of a campaign

Memoirs of Hadrian

Author: Marguerite Yourcenar

Context:

Mentioned as an attempt to mimic Hadrian's voice, described as boring due to being so accurate

Falco series

Author: Lindsey Davis

Context:

Mentioned as detective novels set in ancient Rome that revel in anachronism

Flashman series

Author: George MacDonald Fraser

Context:

Extensively discussed as having excellent narrative voice capturing Victorian cad, praised for ambiguous treatment of empire

A Tale of Two Cities

Author: Charles Dickens

Context:

Argued to be the single most influential novel on how English-speaking world understands the French Revolution

Ivanhoe

Author: Walter Scott

Context:

Described as influential for establishing idea of medieval England as Saxons vs Normans

Gone with the Wind

Author: Margaret Mitchell

Context:

Mentioned as having seismic influence on how people saw the antebellum South, though influence now dissolved

The Virginian

Author: Owen Wister

Context:

Mentioned as the first Wild West novel establishing template for Hollywood westerns

Don Quixote

Author: Miguel de Cervantes

Context:

Discussed as the first novel in modern West, about tension between past and present

The Underground Railroad

Author: Colson Whitehead

Context:

Mentioned as recent novel weaving fantastical into story of slavery to brilliant effect

The Lord of the Rings

Author: J.R.R. Tolkien

Context:

Mentioned as a more creative response to early medieval history than rigorous historical fiction

Terra Nostra

Author: Carlos Fuentes

Context:

Described as counterfactual novel where Philip II marries Elizabeth Tudor and Don Quixote is a character

The Alteration

Author: Kingsley Amis

Context:

Alternate history where England never went Protestant, about a boy about to be castrated to preserve singing voice

Fatherland

Author: Robert Harris

Context:

Mentioned as fantastic alternate history book, remembered reading on a bus desperate to finish

The Years of Rice and Salt

Author: Kim Stanley Robinson

Context:

Alternate history where Black Death wipes out Europeans and Muslims colonize Europe

The Man in the High Castle

Author: Philip K. Dick

Context:

Mentioned as example of alternate history that integrates critique of the genre

Middlemarch

Author: George Eliot

Context:

Mentioned as example of high-status novel set around time of author's birth that counts as historical

Vanity Fair

Author: William Makepeace Thackeray

Context:

Mentioned as great historical novel set around time of author's birth

The Charterhouse of Parma

Author: Stendhal

Context:

Mentioned as 19th century writer writing about events 20-30 years previous

La Débâcle

Author: Émile Zola

Context:

Mentioned as Zola writing about Franco-Prussian War, events 20-30 years before

Waverley

Author: Walter Scott

Context:

Described as classically the first historical novel, set in Jacobite period, chosen as book to survive apocalypse

The Rotter's Club

Author: Jonathan Coe

Context:

Mentioned as example of people writing historical novels set in 70s and 80s

The Northern Clemency

Author: Philip Hensher

Context:

Mentioned alongside Rotter's Club as historical novel set in recent past

A Journal of the Plague Year

Author: Daniel Defoe

Context:

Mentioned as possibly the very first historical novel, written 70 years after Great Plague of London

The Persian Boy

Author: Mary Renault

Context:

Discussed as middle book in Alexander trilogy, narrated by eunuch Bagoas, with vivid castration description

Fire from Heaven

Author: Mary Renault

Context:

Mentioned as first in Alexander trilogy about Alexander's childhood and youth

Blood Meridian

Author: Cormac McCarthy

Context:

Described as powerful favourite book set in 1850s US-Mexico borderlands about scalp hunters

The Road

Author: Cormac McCarthy

Context:

Mentioned in comparison to Blood Meridian's apocalyptic style

Absalom, Absalom!

Author: William Faulkner

Context:

Mentioned as very difficult book looking back to Civil War and slavery in American South

King Arthur and the Knights of the Round Table

Author: Antonia Fraser

Context:

Mentioned by Dominic as the first historical novel he remembers reading as a child